An Indiana appeals court ruled Tuesday that a dispute over workers compensation medical reimbursements between CorVel and a hospital must be resolved by the state’s Workers’ Compensation Board rather than through arbitration.
The Indiana Court of Appeals, in CorVel Corp. v. Memorial Hospital of South Bend, unanimously affirmed a board ruling denying CorVel’s motions to compel arbitration in a dispute with Memorial Hospital of South Bend over payments for medical treatment provided to four employees of CorVel clients.
CorVel, a provider of workers compensation services, entered into a preferred provider organization agreement with the hospital in 1997. The agreement contained an arbitration provision and allowed CorVel to reimburse the hospital based on the lesser of the state’s workers compensation fee schedule or a specified percentage of billed charges.
The hospital challenged CorVel’s application of the statutory fee schedule and filed claims with the board in 2022, 2023 and 2024 seeking additional reimbursement.
CorVel sought to dismiss the claims and compel arbitration under its agreement with the hospital. The board denied the motions, finding that it had jurisdiction over the reimbursement disputes.
On appeal, CorVel argued that the agreement required arbitration and that an arbitrator, rather than the board, should determine whether the disputes were subject to arbitration.
The appeals court disagreed, finding that the agreement did not clearly delegate that determination to an arbitrator.
The court also found that the reimbursement dispute concerned the application of Indiana’s statutory workers compensation fee schedule, not the terms of the parties’ agreement.
Because the dispute did not arise under the agreement, the arbitration provision did not apply, the court ruled.
This article was first published by Business Insurance.